Hyundai Forums banner

Fuel Dilution Of Engine Oil In Plug-in Hybrid *and* Hybrid Tucsons - THERE IS A SEMI-SECRET SOFTWARE UPDATE

17K views 57 replies 19 participants last post by  snootyexponent  
#1 · (Edited)
A lab test following a recent oil change showed that my engine oil had been diluted over 5% by gasoline. 2.4% is the recommended maximum dilution. In 500 miles of driving since that oil change my oil level had risen to 1/2" over the maximum fill line. Many other owners of Hybrid (HEV) and Plug-in Hybrid (PHEV) Tucsons have been reporting similar dilution of their engine oil. The root cause is increased blow-by of gasoline past the piston rings in TGDI (turbocharged gasoline direct injection) engines and then the oil in these very efficient engines never getting hot enough to "boil" off the gasoline. Dilution of the engine oil by gasoline can cause excessive engine wear. (Other brands of automobiles with TGDI engines have reported similar issues.)

The Service Manager at the dealer where I have my Tucson serviced was totally non-responsive, so I had to raise a bit of a ruckus with some 1-star reviews on social media. Once I engaged with the General Manager, things moved very quickly.

When the General Manager spoke with a Hyundai Regional Field Service Engineer he was informed that there was, in fact, a Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) to address the issue of fuel dilution of engine oil in Tucson HEVs and PHEVs. Apparently the Service Department at the dealer was unaware of this TSB.

The TSB Number is 23-EE-002H. It was issued in March, 2023. (With problems of this nature it can often take several tries to fix or mitigate the problem. Be sure to check for updated or superseding TSBs. The General Manager at the dealer said that he would be checking with Hyundai every month or two on my behalf.)

Most of the TSB deals with DTC error codes being issued erroneously. These error codes have nothing to do with the oil dilution issue. At the bottom of the TSB, almost as an afterthought, there is:

Oil Dilution: Some vehicles may experience increased oil consumption and white smoke due to the diluting of engine oil with fuel because of the frequent transition between EV<-->Engine mode during the winter season.​
a. Modify fuel injection strategy below 10 degrees Celsius [50 degrees Fahrenheit] and add oil heating function based on the driving pattern.​

On the TSB, Event #911 is an ECU software upgrade for both HEVs and PHEVs. Event #939 is an HCU software upgrade for HEVs and Event #940 is an HCU software upgrade for PHEVs.

This TSB is NOT being applied to all 2022-23 HEV/PHEV Tucsons. When my VIN is input into the Hyundai system the TSB does not come up as being needed. Hyundai may only be approving the warranty work to install the TSB for the stated symptoms: "increased oil consumption" or "white smoke." You might have to educate your Hyundai dealer's service department about the existence of the TSB and then convince them that a failed lab test for the oil or an oil level above the maximum fill line make your car eligible for the TSB because of the oil being diluted by gasoline.

After applying the TSB the dealer changed my oil. (I confirmed that they used 0W-20 full synthetic oil.) I will note the current oil level and then monitor to see if it rises. If the oil dilution problem does still exist, it may not become evident until next winter.

(Note - These are the DTC error codes also addressed by the semi-secret TSB. I'm listing them here in case somebody is searching the forum for such a code. P1441, P1A77, P00B7, P2118, P0401, P0236, P0299, P2B60.)

Admins - There should be similar TSBs for all other Hyundai and Kia models that use the 1.6L Gamma II turbocharged engine. Please cross-post if possible.
 
#6 ·
Congratulations! You're the first one to ask. You get the golden turd.

Here's what it meant when Jeep updated the firmware on their Wrangler 4xe plug-in hybrid.

The Wrangler 4Xe has a process called 'Fuel Oil Refresh Mode' aka FORM, that is supposed to prevent oil dilution. Jeep engineering put together a pretty good explanation as to how it works:​
In short, the vehicle software monitors your driving and I'm assuming the frequency of cold starts and short run cycles to predict the amount of oil dilution. Based on the model, the Wrangler 4Xe will operate in one of 4 modes:​
· Step 0: Normal Operation: Below a bottom threshold, vehicle operation is normal.​
· Step 1: Moderate fuel dilution: Between the bottom and middle thresholds, silent start allows electric operation during a drive until the first ICE start. After that, you'll see the FORM message and the ICE will continue running until you shut the car off.​
· Step 2: More fuel dilution: Between the middle and top thresholds, EV operation is not allowed. The ICE will start when you power up the vehicle and remain running until you shut down, or the bottom threshold is reached, whichever comes first.​
· Step 3: More fuel dilution: Above the top threshold, EV operation is not allowed, and the vehicle will instruct you to perform an oil change.​
If this is what Hyundai did, say bye-bye to most EV operation in cold weather.
 
#9 · (Edited)
Congratulations! You're the first one to ask. You get the golden turd.

Here's what it meant when Jeep updated the firmware on their Wrangler 4xe plug-in hybrid.

The Wrangler 4Xe has a process called 'Fuel Oil Refresh Mode' aka FORM, that is supposed to prevent oil dilution. Jeep engineering put together a pretty good explanation as to how it works:​
In short, the vehicle software monitors your driving and I'm assuming the frequency of cold starts and short run cycles to predict the amount of oil dilution. Based on the model, the Wrangler 4Xe will operate in one of 4 modes:​

If this is what Hyundai did, say bye-bye to most EV operation in cold weather.
Thanks for the info. I'm skeptical of the "fix". My car fuel dilutes summer and winter (and winters are mild in southern NM). I seldom start my car in temps under 50deg F (10C) even in winter. It's the short trips that are the problem coupled with very slow warm up of the gamma II. The next thing I was going to look at is the exhaust heat recovery system. OEMs are increasingly using these to get engines up to temp quickly and the Tucson HEV is no exception. They supposedly add 3kw of heat to your coolant which is a lot. I don't think there's any electrical connection of the unit to the ECU and thus no warning if it were stuck closed. When I get the ambition, I'm going to crawl up under the car and have a look.

I will wait to see how others fare with the ECU "upgrade". I would hate to have any changes that hurt fuel economy which is great on my blue model.
 
#7 ·
Here you go,, TSB is essentially "if you see this and vehicle under warranty, you is to follow this procedure, otherwise, we may deny claim"

Here is also the Recall, note how all the DTC codes mirror. Just like typical Hyundai way, recall part of them, let the rest come out in the wash. seen this with misfire logic with Elantra, stop light switches, and couple others
 

Attachments

#14 · (Edited)
I received it 2 weeks ago. No idea if that got done before the trek started but after the March TSBs. I must have missed where it says prior to delivery, since this isn't a recall. I'll look again. (Edit: right at the top.)

I do notice when the car first turns on, it won't go into EV mode until the car has been on for a certain amount of time (not sure if that was normal before this).
 
#26 ·
I have a 2019 Tucson PHEV which I've had to take to the dealership twice because of heavy white smoking.
They said the oil was contaminated with some water (see photo) and the reason was that I was not driving enough for the engine to get warm enough for the water to evaporate! I live in Iceland where it can be a little cold in the winter (-5 to -10°C) and drive around 11 km in 11 min to work (one way).
What is your opinion, is this normal? My girlfriend has a hybrid Toyota and drives less distance, but nothing like this has happened in her car.
Image
Image
 
#28 ·
FYI:


This also seemed to several of us to be coolant, but turned out to be oil. It will be interesting to see the results of Mungo544's suggestion.

Be sure to make the dealer aware of the TSB. Since most of us are heading into summer, you might be the first person who could notice the effect of the TSB firmware update.

A PHEV is more susceptible to this issue since as long as the car can run in EV mode the engine just runs at idle as needed for cabin heat.

The Jeep solution (Post #6 above) basically eliminates EV and Hybrid mode driving. We don't yet know what the Hyundai firmware update does.

One thought I've had is to stop charging the car in cold weather and basically run it as a hybrid. That will be a major disappointment, but better than putting the engine at risk. Hybrid Tucsons have reported the issue, but not as severe.

One slight solace is that this issue appears to be somewhat common across various brands and models of Turbocharged Gasoline Direct Injection (TGDI) engines, and not a unique Hyundai defect.
 
#27 ·
Did they drain and refill your engine oil ? If not, don't go back to that dealer. There shouldn't be measureable water in your oil just because you don't get your engine up to temperature. That much water in the oil looks like a head gasket leak to me. Are you having to add coolant periodically? I would drain the oil and put some in a one quart clear glass container to see what percentage of water is in the oil (the oil will separate and float over the water). Anything more than a trace means you likely have a head gasket leak imho. Bring your evidence with you when you return to the dealer.
 
#29 ·
It was a Hyundai official dealership so they changed the oil on both occasions. There is a 7 year warranty so I would assume they needed to fix the engine if it broke down because of the water in the oil? Or perhaps they will blame me for not driving long distances :)
Have not checked the coolant, thanks for the tip. But I dare not drain the oil, so as not to void/affect the warranty.

I read the TSB and it's good to have that as a reference. It sounded from the dealership as my car and driving was an isolated case! But now I have been driving the car for more than a month as a hybrid car and hope most of the water has evaporated. And yes it's a disappointment not being able to use the PHEV as intended.
Perhaps they need to advertise the car differently :)

Thank you for the feedback!
 
#30 ·
It is unclear whether mine has the update applied or not, and I won't find out until the first oil change, but perhaps we can determine from evidence before I reach the first oil change. I have noticed when I start the car, it must reach about 1/5 of the temperature max in the bar graph/diagram on the instrument cluster before it allows for EV mode use. Do others with pre-2023 models see the same behavior? If I hooked up an OBD II device to the car, you think it would give me the actual oil temperature or engine temperature, or would I need a Hyundai-specific tablet?
 
#31 ·
Possibly different than my (pre-update) Tucson, but it could also be a confusing dash display. When starting out in cold weather last winter my Tucson would be running in EV mode but would also be running the ICE at a steady 1100 RPM or 1500 RPM depending on the outside or cabin temperature (I'm not sure which). The green EV display symbol would NOT be on while the ICE was idling, but the tachometer clearly showed that the ICE wasn't being used for propulsion, just for cabin heat. If you haven't done so already, turn on the tachometer display to see clearly if the car is in EV mode but not showing the EV display symbol.

If EV mode is being suppressed until the ICE warms up, that does sound like a different behavior.
 
#34 ·
We've driven 550 miles. Almost all of it has been short trips. We've used just 6 gallons of gas. Temps here have been in the 40s most of the days we've driven. I think that counts as exactly the situation where we should expect gas in our oil. We checked the oil yesterday. It was not above max. It sat right in the middle of the "good" zone. The oil looked pristine, a nice, clean yellow. Our car was manufactured early in 2023. Any chance the program for the car has been changed to prevent the gas-in-the-oil issue?
 
#35 ·
I had a phone conversation with Tech Support at Amsoil.

They use gas chromatography to measure fuel dilution of oil, which is more accurate than the Flash Point method used by Blackstone.


The viscosity of my oil had dropped to 6.0 centistokes at 100 deg. C., which is a little lower than 16. The oil started out as 0W-20.

They are seeing increasing instances of fuel dilution with the increased numbers of direct injection engines in use.

The technician said that modern oils can handle some degree of dilution while retaining their ability to lubricate. He said that the most important measurements to keep an eye on are wear metals, watching for changes over time or the exceeding of thresholds in a given sample. Amsoil measures iron, chromium, nickel, aluminum, copper, lead, tin, cadmium, silver and vanadium. Unfortunately they do not publish the thresholds on their test report unless a particular contaminant exceeds the threshold.

Interpreting wear metal trends needs to take into account how long the oil has been in service when it is sampled. ("Normalizing" the test results.) Without a measure of operating hours mileage has to be that measure, but in PHEVs and HEVs this is complicated because some proportion of those miles are in EV mode.

I was able to find an Amsoil training publication that does a good job of explaining their methodologies and how to interpret their results.


Be sure to read the footnotes.

Side note - Amsoil sells a sampling device that allows taking oil samples without having to drain the oil.
 
#41 ·
My first run indicates about 130F for EV mode access, which is only slightly above that number. A quick Google search indicates that gasoline starts to vaporize at 140F for what it's worth. Presumably yours doesn't have the TSB update, though, correct? If so, that would imply, albeit with the one data point caveat, that either something else was done than simply requiring the engine to run more, or my car doesn't have the TSB update, either.
 
#52 ·
Hopefully they have fixed this with the newer SmartStream 1.6L turbo engines. I know they have completely redone the PCV system, now using a Pressure Regulation Valve that is built into the rocker cover like some VW/AUDI and Volvo's. If anyone has more info on this I would love to hear about it. They may even have a built-in oil separator. Anyone know?
 
#54 ·
Hi, I have a 2022 Tucson 1.6 hybrid 2wd auto with 15k km based in sunny Costa Blanca Spain. Recently I noticed the oil level had increased in the engine and the oil was noticeable dirtier. I got the car to my dealer where they diagnosed a faulty high pressure fuel pump! They changed the pump, oil and filter and have assured me this will fix the problem, but having seen your thread and not able to understand how the pump could influence the oil level. Will keep an eye on the levels even more now. Have you heard of this “fix” before? ( This is my first post so apologies for any errors)
 
#55 ·
The pump is run by a cam on the top of the engine. If it develops a leak while it is providing fuel pressure of up to 5,000 PSI! it will leak directly into the top of the engine where it will flow right into the oil passages, diluting the oil. It really is simple and easy for this to happen and has been a known issue for some time now.
 
#58 ·
@Captain Blight Have you considered what premium fuel might do to our GDI engines? I know premium fuel is not required, but several other forums on Bob is the Oil guy have some reasoning why higher octane may lead to less fuel being injected, and subsequently less fuel dilution. Not a panacea but apparently will reduce the dilution.

I'm running a few tanks of 93 Costco Top Tier gas, and will see. Obviously, this doesn't replace shorter OCIs and moving up in oil weight (going to switch to 5W-30 instead of OW-20).