Took the 2.0t in for it's first oil change this past weekend and heard a strange sound just as I was turning into the dealer. They were supposed to check out the odd rattling noise I've been having on cold starts, but I was then informed that my passenger side front inner fender well was smashed up and had been rubbing on the wheel. They said I must have hit something and the clip broke and the piece was shredded from rubbing on the tire, which is odd since neither my wife nor myself recall hitting anything with it, but maybe we caught a rock just right (so far we aren't having a lot of luck with this car). Anywho, just wondering if anyone has any experience replacing this? From what I can tell it's just a bunch of the plastic plugs holding it on, however the dealer wants to charge me 1.5 hours of work to do it? The plastic piece itself is $110. We're also getting a noticeable rattling on the car, which I'm hoping is just that loose front piece catching the wind.